There are significant differences in the different types of trumpet valves and in particular the piston and rotary pipes. In additional, the differences in these valves alter the kinds of results that you can achieve as you play a trumpet that is fitted with any of these types of valves. There are many areas in which these two types of valves differ from each other. For instance, the way they travel in their casings, the manner in which they seal, the kind of bracing used, the design of the valve, and the weight of these valves are some of the things that distinguish pistons from rotaries.
Additionally, the difference between them means that each type of valve is capable of creating different elements. That is why for a person who loves this wind instrument and has a keen interest in polishing their trumpeting skills and improving their playing experience, understanding the difference between these two types of valves is important. Getting to know how each one of these two valves differs from each other will enable you to find out what are the relative advantages and disadvantages of these types of valves.
In this article, we are going to take a comprehensive look at this topic. We shall examine the main areas that differentiate pistons from rotaries. So, I welcome you to keep on reading this post until the end so that you can understand more.
The intensity of maintenance
The first apparent difference between these two valves is the magnitude of maintaining them. Rotary valves require higher levels of maintenance compared to their piston counterparts. As a trumpet player and owner, you will be required to oil them less frequently as opposed to pistons which do not need that much maintenance. You will have to apply different oils that include a medium thick oil to grease the external valve and thin oil for the rotor. Additionally, you will be required to pull out the 1st and 3rd slides every time you need to empty them. In addition, it takes more time to let out water out of trumpet fitted with rotary valves than it takes to remove from one fitted with piston valves.
The ease or difficulty of valving
Another major area of difference between these valves is the ease or difficulty with which you can navigate the valving processes. With a rotary valve, you will enjoy lesser ease of half-valving and your ability to bend the notes makes the trumpet less suitable for Jazz and more ideal for classical music.
Additionally, the lever travel of the valve is shorter and hence it makes half-valving a bit difficult. The spring tension of the rotary valve is higher compared to the piston one and this height makes it necessary for a user to have very strong fingers so as to navigate well.
The ability to blend with other instruments
Another difference between these two types of valves revolves around the way they allow a trumpet to blend with other musical instruments. Pistons permit a trumpet to produce a sound that stands out above the other musical instruments that it is accompanying. On the other hand, trumpets that are fitted with rotary valves produce a mellow-like sound that harmonizes well with other wind instruments it is accompanying.
The quality of tone
Rotary valve trumpets have a slightly different tone quality that is usually broader than piston valves. Also, they are very difficult to overblow and can take a lot of air so you can play very loudly.
The holding position
Trumpets fitted with rotary valves are flatter in shape compared to their piston valve counterparts. This difference in the form of the two types of trumpet valves allows for different styles of holding the trumpet as you blow them. For instance, you will need to hold a rotary system trumpet as if you are nibbling on a hamburger.
The sharpness and flatness of the intonation
There is also a slight difference in the intonation of the two forms of valves. For instance, rotary valves have a flatter tone compared to their piston counterparts. They go flatter in the classical upper register, and they are ideal for users who go sharp in this particular area.
The way they are played
Another main area of difference comes in the way the valves are played, and let’s take the piston valve as our first example. For you to play the pistons, you need to press the first piston which allows air to flow through the first slide. When you press the second and third piston, the pressing will cause air to pass through the second and third slides as well. It is the pressing process that allows air paths to elongate.
But things are a bit different with the rotary valves. When you press the lever and turn the rotary 90 degrees, it alters the flowing of air in the trumpet. As you play the trumpet, the tube remains shorter if you don’t press the lever, and longer when you push the lever.
Their scope of use
Regarding their geographical scope of popularity, rotary valves gained popularity in Germany and Austria, while the trumpets that have piston valves were widely accepted in countries such as France.
The positioning of the valves
When you play trumpets that are fitted with these two types of valves, you feel a slight difference in their positioning. For example, piston valves will give you a more centered feel than rotary ones.
The flexibility of the valves is another thing that sets a clear difference between pistons and rotaries. The piston valve is more flexible in its technical passages as opposed to the rotary which is less flexible. Also, the rotary has a darker and more resonant timbre that is suitable for use in Bruckner and Strauss.
The cylindrical bore
Rotary valves have a cylindrical bore that is smaller compared to that of their piston counterpart, but their lead pipe and bell are larger than those of the piston. In addition, trumpets with rotary valves have a wider pattern that is intended to avoid curves in the tubing while those with piston have a narrower pattern.